• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • NBCNews.com
  • TODAY
  • Nightly News
  • Rock Center
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • msnbc
  • Breaking News
  • Newsvine
  • Home
  • US
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Local
  • Weather
Advertise | AdChoices
  • Recommended: Will China mediate the Israeli-Palestinian peace process?
  • Recommended: 'Get out': Over 1,000 take to the streets in China to protest oil refinery
  • Recommended: Chinese spooked by food scandals take action - by growing it themselves
  • Recommended: A Nixon returns to China, retracing steps of 1972 visit

In Behind the Wall, NBC News correspondents and producers examine events and trends in China, both big and small.

  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • 12
    May
    2013
    6:32am, EDT

    A Nixon returns to China, retracing steps of 1972 visit

    President Richard Nixon's grandson, Christopher Cox Nixon, recently visited a much-changed China, more than 30 years after his grandfather's historic trip changed U.S.-Chinese relations forever.

    By Ian Williams, correspondent, NBC News

    BEIJING -- Christopher Cox Nixon began retracing the steps of his grandfather's historic 1972 visit to China by walking across Tiananmen Square with an entourage that included several former Nixon aides.

    "The stark contrast between then and now," marveled Jack Brennan, who had accompanied President Richard Nixon to China as his Marine Corp aide. "The colors, and nobody smiled back then."

    As if on cue, a young Chinese woman in a bright dress, big white-rimmed sunglasses and a smile that seemed as broad as the Tiananmen Gate, bounded forward requesting a photograph. Although not with Brennan, but with the young Nixon's glamorous wife, Andrea Catsimatidis, clad in a striking red dress.

    Catsimatidis, daughter of supermarket billionaire John Catsimatidis -- a candidate for mayor of New York -- duly obliged, as she would several more times as the group strolled on through the Forbidden City.

    It is likely that none of the Chinese fans had a clue who she was -- and they may never have heard of either of the Nixons. But it seemed a cool thing to do, uploading the photo from a smartphone to one of the many social networking sites patronized by young Chinese.

    Yes, this country has changed.

    Andy Wong / AP

    In this combo photo, U.S. President Richard Nixon and his wife Pat Nixon have light moments at a huge stone elephant, left, on Feb. 24, 1972; while at right, Nixon's grandson Christopher Cox and his wife Andrea Catsimatidisat visit the same spot at the Ming Tomb, north of Beijing, on  May 4, 2013.

    President Nixon called his historic 1972 visit "the week that changed the world," ending 25 years of a diplomatic freeze between the two countries. The young Nixon’s visit marked the centenary of his grandfather's birth.

    "What an incredible change from 40 years ago," said the young Nixon, a 34-year-old investment banker with political ambitions of his own. "Just look at the personal freedoms, not political freedoms, but personal freedoms -- how people dress, how people interact with each other."

    The 1972 trip is credited with opening China to the world. It was also an important Cold War play, driving a deeper wedge between China and the Soviet Union. Nixon was fiercely anti-communist, and the term "Nixon going to China" became a catchphrase for an unexpected action by a politician.

    "We should never keep a billion of the world's most able and hard-working people in isolation," said his grandson. "I think that he [President Nixon] would have expected to see the Chinese people so prosperous and industrious."

    The anniversary trip was designed to stress the positives of both the Nixon administration and the Chinese Communist Party, which gave the group red-carpet treatment as they traveled last week to Beijing, Shanghai and Hangzhou.

    One highlight was a banquet at the Great Hall of the People, hosted by State Councilor Yang Jiechi, China's top foreign policy official, and designed to mirror a banquet thrown for President Nixon.

    A big screen at the front of the room described the 1972 summit as the "most important event in the history of international diplomacy in the 20th century."

    Andy Wong / AP

    Christopher Cox, grandson of former U.S. President Richard Nixon, second from right, and his wife Andrea Catsimatidis, third from right, pose with Chinese tourists as they tour the Great Wall of China at Badaling, north of Beijing, on May 4. A delegation led by Cox is here to commemorate Nixon's centennial by retracing his 1972 historical visit to China.

    Among the Chinese dignitaries was Tang Wensheng, who had been interpreter for Chairman Mao Zedong back then. Mao had suffered a stroke a few days before Nixon arrived, and she said the Chinese side was worried about whether Mao would be well enough. But the ailing Mao was able to meet Nixon.

    Robert McFarlane, former national security adviser to President Nixon, said the summit set the scene for extensive sharing of privileged information.

    "We shared the most sensitive intelligence about the Soviet Union with China, intelligence we didn't even share with our allies," he said.

    He said this was designed as a mark of sincerity, but it also served Washington's purpose of further poisoning relations between the two communist giants.

    Back then, of course, relations between China and the U.S. were fairly simple -- there weren't any.

    Today China is a much more open, yet complicated, place. Relations can be tense and difficult. The two are economic and political rivals, and U.S. officials are much more regular visitors as they grapple with a host of issues from cyberspying to North Korea. 

    "The problems haven't become any easier," McFarlane said. "Issues like cybersecurity, regional territorial disagreements between China and her neighbors and certainly terrorism -- all of these look daunting."

    As the toasts got underway, there was much talk at the banquet of reviving the spirit of 1972.

    "It’s important for the two countries to talk to each other frankly," McFarlane said.

    Related links: 

    Chairman Mao's granddaugher makes China's rich list 

    China labels US the 'real hacking empire' after Pentagon report 

    'Charlie Two Shoes': A story of wartime loyalty and friendship

    103 comments

    Maybe if the libs are so opposed to anything dealing with China, they could get their incompetent president "KING HUSSINE" to cease spending taxpayer money that we have to borrow from these people???

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, gop, beijing, richard-nixon, foreign-policy, 1972, featured, ian-williams, christopher-cox-nixon
  • Updated
    5
    May
    2013
    9:43am, EDT

    'Charlie Two Shoes': A story of wartime loyalty and friendship

    As a boy, "Charlie Two Shoes" was adopted by U.S. Marines stationed in China after World War II. His old Marine buddies helped him emigrate from Communist China to the U.S. in 1983. Some of those friends joined Charlie when he recently returned to a much-changed China for the first time in 30 years. NBC's Ian Williams reports.

    By Ian Williams, correspondent, NBC News

    BEIJING – Next weekend, an 80-year-old Chinese American called Charlie Tsui will give the commencement address at the College of the Ozarks in Missouri.

    The events which shaped Tsui's life took place well before any of the 270 students receiving their bachelor degrees were born, though his story of loyalty and friendship easily bridges the generational divide.

    Tsui was born in a village just outside the Chinese coastal city of Qingdao, which is where he first met U.S. Marines, stationed there at the end of the World War II. He lived in a hut just beyond the barbed wire of the Marine compound. It was a time of immense turmoil in China, which was gripped by a civil war that would eventually lead to the Communists taking over in 1949.

    Tsui would bring the Marines boiled eggs and warm peanuts from his village.

    The Marines adopted him, gave Tsui food and clothes, taught him English and paid for him to go to the American school in the city. They also gave him a nickname: “Charlie Two Shoes,” since his original Chinese name, Tsui Chi Hsii, was tough to pronounce.

    NBC News

    Charlie Tsui, nicknamed "Charlie Two Shoes" as a child by the U.S. Marines who became like brothers to him in Qingdao, China after World War II.

    "We were like brothers in the Marine Corps," he recalls. "We love each other, just like brother and sister."

    But the Marines were not able to take Tsui with them when they left shortly before the Communists took control.

    "Leaving him over there when I left in 1947, it was like leaving a wounded Marine behind," said Don Sexton, who was squad leader back then.

    NBC News

    Charlie Tsui as a child in Qingdao, China after World War II.

    For years, the Marines heard nothing of Tsui, who was jailed and then kept under house arrest for seven years for refusing to denounce his Marine buddies.

    In 1983, Tsui did manage to get a letter out, and NBC News was able to track him down. The timing was good, as China was opening up, and the Marines campaigned successfully to get him a visa for the US, his family joining him two years later. He was soon running a successful restaurant business in Chapel Hill, N.C., which of course was the scene over the years of many a Marine reunion.

    But having gotten to the U.S., seemingly in the face of massive odds, he then faced a 17-year-battle with the Immigration and Naturalization Service. He came close to deportation before gaining legal residency and ultimately citizenship under a 1992 law prompted by the Tiananmen Square massacre.

    "He was one special person. Now he's like family," said Carl Frost, one of those Marines.

    In 2002, Tsui was made an "honorary Marine" in an official ceremony at Camp Lejeune. 

    Frost and Sexton were among the members of Tsui's Marine family who recently returned to Qingdao with Tsui for the first time since he left all those years ago. Also on the trip were students from the College of the Ozarks, which sponsored the visit. The college has a program that pairs students with American veterans, taking them back to their battlefields or military stations.

    Today's Qingdao is a very different place, with modern glistening buildings and brash prosperity. NBC News also joined the trip as an at times bewildered Charlie Two Shoes sought out the landmarks of his childhood.

    NBC News

    Charlie Tsui and a group of his old Marine buddies return to Qingdao, China for the first time in 30 years.

    "That was the cave where the Japanese stored their weapons," he said, pointing at the craggy rocks just beyond what is now a sports field, but had been a military parade ground, during the Japanese occupation of the city.

    The old Marines barracks has long since been reclaimed by the city's university. "That's where I slept, up the end there," he said, pointing down a long corridor.

    The old American School is now an elite kindergarten. Remarkably, Tsui's old family home still stands, though much expanded by the migration workers now living there. His village, Chukechuang, has become part of the city's sprawling suburbs. This is where he met an elder brother he'd thought was dead.

     "I was worried. He's alright. He's alright," he said, as the two stood gripping each other's hands.

    The man called "Charlie Two Shoes" by his old U.S. Marine friends leaves China. NBC's Tom Brokaw and Sandy Gilmour report on May 9, 1983.

    When the Americans left, Tsui had moved into an orphanage run by nuns, which is where he developed a strong Christian faith, which he says kept him going through those hard times.

    St. Michael's Cathedral, where he received his first communion, still stands - a city landmark. Tsui would walk 10 miles, there and back, to worship on Sundays until the Communists shut it down.

    Tsui's return visit was during a big Chinese holiday. The beach and promenade at Qingdao was packed. For a moment Tsui was lost in thought, before recalling where the last of the American ships were loaded before leaving. Back then he thought he'd never see his Marine buddies again. But he never gave up hope.

    Related links:

    More NBC News reporting on China in Behind the Wall

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    This story was originally published on Thu May 2, 2013 4:40 PM EDT

    74 comments

    I wish there were more stories out there like this! Not every foreigner is an enemy combatant.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, world-war-ii, us-marines, communism, mao, updated, ian-williams
  • Updated
    24
    Apr
    2013
    7:57am, EDT

    New bird flu strain 'one of most lethal' influenza viruses

    Wang Zhao / AFP - Getty Images

    A new strain of bird flu identified in China "is one of the most lethal influenza viruses we have seen so far," Dr. Keiji Fukuda, the World Health Organization (WHO)'s Assistant Director-General for Health Security, tells journalists at a press conference in Beijing on Wednesday.

    By Ian Williams, correspondent, NBC News

    BEIJING – A new type of bird flu that has killed 22 people in China since March is one of the most deadly strains of influenza known, international health experts said on Wednesday. 

    "This is one of the most lethal influenza viruses we have seen so far," said Dr. Keiji Fukuda, the World Health Organization (WHO)’s Assistant Director-General for Health Security. "We are at the beginning of our understanding of this virus."

    The H7N9 strain appears to spread more easily to humans than SARS, a different virus that started killing people in Asia a decade ago, experts said. Severe acute respiratory syndrome killed around 800 people globally in 2003 before it was stopped.

    "This is an unusually dangerous virus for humans," added Fukuda, who was speaking in Beijing alongside leading flu experts from around the world.  

    The delegation from United States, Europe, Hong Kong and Australia, as well as China, have just concluded a week-long investigation that took them to affected areas in Shanghai and Beijing.

    Little is known
    The group of experts made an impressive display of international cooperation, but at the same time admitted just how little is known about the virus that has infected 108 people since March.

    "We are at the very early stages of this investigation," said Dr. Nancy Cox, who heads Influenza Division at the Center for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta. "There's a lot to be learned.”

    A four-year-old boy living in a village near Beijing has been confirmed as one the carriers of a deadly strain of bird flu virus. Until the weekend, the outbreak had appeared to be confined to Shanghai and other eastern areas but now it's spread to central and northern China. NBC's Ian Williams reports from Beijing.

    Most of the cases so far have been found in eastern China, around the Yangtze River delta, but in recent days there have been cases in central and northern China, including the capital. Most have been what Fukuda called "sporadic cases."  

    He said a few family clusters have been found, which could be the result of exposure to the same source of virus, or limited person-to-person transmission.

    But he said: "'Evidence so far is not sufficient to conclude there is person-to-person transmission. Moreover, no sustained person-to-person transmission has been found.”

    The experts concluded that live poultry markets were the most likely source of infection.

    The experts praised the swift action of Chinese authorities in closing live poultry markets, and said it was "encouraging" that there have been no new cases in Shanghai since its markets were shuttered.

    And they called for continued international cooperation against a virus that doesn't recognize borders. 

    "The risks of an outbreak situation are shared in a globalized world, where we are all interconnected," said Fukuda.

    Legacy of distrust
    All of those who spoke today went out of their way to praise the response and of the Chinese authorities and their openness and transparency. There is enormous sensitivity to any suggestion that their presence in China implies any criticism of local efforts.

    China still lives in the shadow of the SARS pandemic, which began here a decade ago and killed hundreds worldwide, including in the U.S. It was made worse by an initial cover-up by the Chinese authorities.

    Dr. Jeffrey Shaman, Columbia University, tells NBC's Robert Bazell why flu comes in the winter and if the weather has anything to do with it.    

    "The response reflects earlier and strong investments in health and preparedness made by China," said Fukuda.

    SARS also left a legacy of distrust, which was on display earlier in the week in Shanghai, when a press conference by the local government and WHO was gatecrashed by the daughter of a couple infected with H7N9. The 26-year-old demanded information about her quarantined father; her mother had died.

    "The hospitals and medical staff appear friendly to members of the media like you but have responded in a lukewarm manner to inquiries from family members like me," she told the South China Morning Post. She was taken away by officials.

    The experts said that in the absence of so much basic information about the extent of the public health risk it was critical to maintain a high level of awareness. They also noted that the weather is warming up in China, which might provide a bit of a respite and buy them some important time, since H7N9 -- in common with other influenza -- spreads less easily in the spring and summer.

    Related:

    • A new openness as new bird flu virus spreads in China
    • Six more diagnosed with new bird flu in China
    • Scientists ready to re-start bird flu experiments

    This story was originally published on Wed Apr 24, 2013 6:19 AM EDT

    163 comments

    Why does all this stuff start from China? Is this natures way of thinning out the herd?! I wonder if it's the fact that it's so polluted over there, that everything gets immune to the surroundings. I mean, they have to wear surgical masks just to go outside, the rivers run rainbow colors etc.... The …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, health, bird-flu, influenza, featured, sars, updated, ian-williams, h7n9
  • 11
    Apr
    2013
    6:38am, EDT

    China grows weary of North Korea's 'chaos and conflict'

    As Kerry heads to Seoul, South Korea, tensions with North Korea continue to rise as it remains unclear whether or not the latest rhetoric is merely Kim Jong-un showing off his military strength. NBC's Andrea Mitchell reports.

    By Ian Williams, correspondent, NBC News

    News Analysis

    BEIJING -- There was confusion at the China-North Korea border Thursday after Chinese tour operators halted trips into the North.

    Wang Zhao / AFP - Getty Images

    Two men wait Thursday for dispatch at a customs port in the Chinese border city of Dandong. The largest border crossing between North Korea and China has been closed to tourist groups, a Chinese official said Wednesday.

    It wasn't clear whether the instruction to do so came from the Chinese authorities, the North Koreans, or was made by the nervous operators themselves.

    But it mirrored a wider confusion over Chinese policy toward Pyongyang, which depends on Beijing for food and fuel, as well as diplomatic support.

    As North Korea readies what is thought to be a missile test, China's Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei has spent most of the week deflecting questions with the official line that "all sides" should show restraint and begin dialogue, and that peace and stability are a "shared responsibility."

    But in an interview with NBC News he was more forthright about China's growing concern. "We do not want to see chaos and conflict on China's doorstep," he said.

    In fact, there are signs that China is rethinking its policy toward the North. President Xi Jinping last weekend told a forum of political and business leaders that no country "should be allowed to throw a region and even the whole world into chaos for selfish gain." He didn't mention the North by name, but it was pretty clear who he was referring to.

    Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel described North Korea's actions and "bellicose rhetoric" as "skating very close to a dangerous line."  NBC's Richard Engel reports.

    Earlier, China's Foreign Minister Wang Yi had told UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon that Beijing would not allow "troublemaking on China's doorstep," a line repeated in an editorial in Thursday's China Daily.

    China also supported the latest UN sanctions that followed North Korea's third nuclear test.

    In fact, relations between the two have been souring for some time as Pyongyang has consistently ignored calls by Beijing for restraint.

    "To many in Beijing, North Korea is looking less like a strategic asset and more like a strategic burden," said Cheng Xiaohe, associate professor at Renmin University's School of International Studies.

    In the past, even when clearly unhappy, Beijing has treated the North with kid gloves because of fear of the North collapsing, and also as a hedge against U.S. power in Asia.

    'Little Fatty'
    According to leaked 2010 diplomat cables obtained by Wikileaks and posted by newspapers the Guardian and the New York Times, Chinese officials described the regime in the North as behaving like a "spoiled child."

    Slideshow: North Korea's young leader, Kim Jong Un

    The youngest son of Kim Jong Il succeeded his late father in 2011, becoming the third member of his family to rule the unpredictable and reclusive communist state.

    Launch slideshow

    Chinese social media, which is as close a barometer of public opinion as you can get here, has in recent days been buzzing with criticism -- not of the U.S., but of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, for leading his country to disaster and the world close to war.

    Kim is derided as "Little Fatty" or "Fatty the Third."

    One former top U.S. diplomat agrees there are clear signs that China is losing patience with North Korea. Kurt Campbell, the state department's top official for east asia, said there are signs that a relationship once described by Chairman Mao to be "as close as lips and teeth" is wearing thin.

    He said this was notable in public statements and private conversations with U.S. officials. Speaking last week at a forum at Johns Hopkins University, he said this had the potential for a large impact on northeast Asia.

    What's harder to say is how this growing frustration will be translated into concrete actions to pressure the North.

    Cheng of Renmin University noted that in 2003 Beijing turned off the oil supply in order to force Pyongyang to join six-party talks and could use that weapon again.

    Secret filming captures N. Korean smugglers sneaking into China to get supplies for their impoverished country, as a refugee tells of the horror of life under Kim Jong Un. ITN's Angus Walker reports.

    "If China has political will, China can do something," he said. "China can make a difference."

    Secretary of State John Kerry will be taking this up with China's leaders when he is there this weekend.

    "China and the U.S. share common interests in peace, stability and denuclearisation," said the Foreign Ministry's Hong Lei. "We hope to work with the U.S. side towards that end."

    Significantly, there has so far been no Chinese criticism of the display of U.S. high-tech firepower in the region, which is seen as another tacit condemnation of Pyongyang's antics.

    That said, Kerry will no doubt point out, as other officials have done privately, that if China fails to act the result will be an even bigger U.S. military presence in the region and a possible regional arms race -- precisely what China has said it wants to avoid.

    Related:

    US on missile watch as North Korea celebrates

    Full North Korea coverage from NBC News

    Slideshow: Glimpses into the hermit kingdom of North Korea

    David Guttenfelder / AP

    As chief Asia photographer for the Associated Press, David Guttenfelder has had unprecedented access to communist North Korea. Here's a rare look at daily life in the secretive country.

    Launch slideshow

    403 comments

    China is growing weary of Un? Well here's a plan. Much like when you go outside after a rainstorm and see a bloated little slug meandering down your walkway, what do you do? What you do is put your foot squarely on it and squish it into non-existence because you can.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: un, china, world, north-korea, beijing, state-department, john-kerry, foreign-ministry, pyongyang, ban-ki-moon, little-fatty, xi-jinping, kim-jong-un, ian-williams, wang-yi
  • 5
    Feb
    2013
    10:05pm, EST

    'Friends' lives on at Beijing version of Central Perk

    Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

    By Eun Kyung Kim, TODAY contributor
    Ross and Rachel and all their “Friends” went off the air nearly a decade ago, but the wildly popular sitcom remains a huge favorite with one Chinese fan, who runs a “Central Perk” café in Beijing.

    The coffee shop is modeled after the familiar set from the NBC series, right down to the instantly recognizable oversize orange couch. And while customers may not get to see Chandler, Joey or Phoebe, they will get served by “Rachel,” since all the servers go by that name.

    "I'm crazy about ‘Friends,’” the shop’s owner, Du Xin, told TODAY. How obsessed is he with the show? Du goes by the nickname Gunther, which was the name of the bleached-blond owner of the fictitious Central Perk who pined for Rachel (played by Jennifer Aniston) on the NBC sitcom.

    “Friends” aired from 1994 to 2004, and Du said he has watched all 236 episodes repeatedly. The show runs on a continual loop on his shop’s large-screen television and serves as a learning tool for people interested in mastering colloquial English.

    The café’s menu is inspired by items served on the show, including the infamous “stolen cheesecake” from season seven.

    “A lot of people know cheesecake from ‘Friends’ in China,” Du said.

    Many of the shop’s patrons may be too young to remember when the shows originally aired, but like a good cup of coffee, they savor the strong friendships forged in the series, and view the show’s characters as lifestyle guides.

    “We admire their lifestyle very much. We want to be like the characters in the show,” one patron explained to TODAY.

    There have even been five marriage proposals in the Beijing Central Perk, inspired by the episode in which Monica famously proposed to Chandler.

    The popularity of the café prompted Du to recently open a second Central Perk location in Shanghai.

     

    1 comment

    Can't decide if this is cool or weird...

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, cafe, friends, today-show, ian-williams
  • 10
    Dec
    2012
    3:56am, EST

    Hong Kong offers insight into storm prep

    Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

     

    Hong Kong gets slammed with seven tropical storms a year on average and escapes flooding with a drainage system that looks like a set from a James Bond movie. NBC’s Ian Williams reports.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: weather, china, hong-kong, typhoon, featured, sandy, ian-williams
  • 12
    Nov
    2012
    3:57am, EST

    Communist Party's Congress grinds on amid widespread indifference in China

    Peter Parks / AFP - Getty Images

    Chinese President Hu Jintao is seen speaking at the opening of the 18th Communist Party Congress on a television in a subway train in Shanghai on Nov. 8.

    By Ian Williams, NBC News

    BEIJING -- I arrived in Beijing for what the Global Times, a Chinese newspaper, described as “one of the biggest political events in history.”

    “Are you watching?” I asked my driver on the way in from the airport. He looked at me and laughed. “Why would I watch that?” he replied.

    A little later I settled down in my hotel bar over a glass of Great Wall cabernet sauvignon.  “Are you watching the Congress?” I asked my server. Again that quizzical look. “Oh, I don’t care about that,” she replied, before slipping behind the bar and resuming whatever she was doing on her mobile phone, which judging by her concentration she did care about very much.

    The 18th Congress of the Communist Party of China (CPC) has begun with great pomp and ceremony in the Great Hall of the People on Tiananmen Square. It is important -- a once-in-a-decade leadership change at a time when the country is facing enormous challenges, from a faltering economy to rampant corruption that goes to the core of the party.

    China launches once-in-a-decade changing of guard

    But among many Chinese, away from the stuffy heart of this city (from which carrier pigeons have been banned, incidentally, as a security precaution), the meeting might as well be taking place on the moon, among green aliens with spiky heads.

    That's how relevant it seems to them.

    The official media has given it blanket coverage, while at the same time trying to limit discussion in China's vibrant social media -- slowing internet speeds and even blocking the Chinese translation for the 18th Congress from search engines.

    Aside from the pigeon ban, taxis are required to keep their back windows locked, presumably to prevent the distribution of subversive pamphlets, and tiny remote-controlled aircraft have been outlawed.

    24 hours after President Barack Obama was re-elected to the White House, the world's other major power, China, began the very different process of choosing its new leader. It happens once every ten years, and lasts just a week. And in case there was any doubt, the ruling Communist Party began by pledging never to have Western democracy. NBC's Angus Walker reports.

    Still, the party “will continue to inject vigor to national politics,” declared the Global Times at the weekend.

    “Vigor” isn’t the first world that comes to mind when you see the line up of gray men (you’ll be hard pressed to find many woman near the top of the CPC) in gray suites, gathering mostly to dutifully endorse decisions already made.

    Throwback: China's ex-president flexes power broker muscle in Beijing

    Much of the proceedings are behind closed doors and the main qualification for advancement in the party is to not the rock the boat. Opinions are dangerous; flamboyance can be fatal to a career in the CPC.

    Diego Azubel / EPA

    The party is expected to use the highly orchestrated event to persuade the nation's 1.3 billion people that it can provide another 10 years of economic growth and social stability while curbing corruption and nepotism.

    The report from the retiring party boss and head of state, Hu Jintao, which kicked off the Congress, hailed as a masterpiece by Chinese newspapers, was of such length and mind-boggling tedium that initially it left analysts struggling to figure what precisely whether it was reformist, reactionary, liberal or conservative.

    Probably all of the above.

    Just ahead of Congress, I had embarked on a journey across the Beijing to test opinion. It was hardly scientific, but I figured I'd at least get a sense of what ordinary Chinese were thinking.

    I started by bike in the narrow alleyways around the surviving hutongs in an older part of the city.

    Here the residents are older too, and a question from a foreigner about the Communist Party, produces an embarrassed wave of the hand, or provokes a speedy retreat behind closed doors. Ordinary Chinese of a certain age have seen how capricious and brutal the party can be and know better than to openly discuss politics with a foreigner.

    Despite deadly week, Communist Party says Tibetans 'feel very happy'

    An exception was an elderly man who stood bold upright and recited how China's new leaders would build a strong and prosperous country. But what of Xi Jinping, the man soon to be anointed leader. What does he stand for, how exactly will he do that, I asked. The door swung open and he too was gone.

    I approached a man barbecuing some skewered lamb. He claimed not to understand my interpreter, though did I detect an extra touch of aggression with those skewers at the mention of the party?

    I then took a taxi figuring that cabbies everywhere have an opinion. But not this one, shaking his head, waving his hand, and probably wishing his wheezing vehicle had an ejector seat. I pressed on. I know what President Obama listens to on his iPod, I explained, and what Mitt Romney has for breakfast. Did he think Xi Jinping has an iPod?

    At that he just burst out laughing, and laughed, and laughed, until he dropped me at a Beijing university, where my luck changed.

    While the candidates are scrutinized and skewered by the media in the U.S., China's new leader Xi Jinping remains a man of mystery among his citizens. NBC's Ian Williams reports

    Here almost all the youngsters I met had heard of Xi, but professed to know hardly anything about him. What does he stand for? Two young women looked blankly at each other. "We don’t know," they said in unison, as if this was the most stupid question they'd ever heard. Does Xi have kids? I asked another couple. "I don't know," said one. "And I don't care." said the other.

    Another young man looked puzzled. "But we don't vote," he said, which I guess goes to the heart of the matter. Why should we care, he seemed to be saying, what's this process got to do with us?

    Perhaps out of desperation, I did what a lot of Beijingers are doing these days and went to a fortune teller. He rumbled me immediately, and declared that he didn’t do politics, and that his crystal ball certainly didn't stretch to the Communist Party. "I don't know and I don’t care," he declared.

    The party, at least its more perceptive members, do seem to recognize the challenges they -- and China -- face. But the prescription for these ills appears to be more of the same. Its still a brave and lonely voice that will call for greater openness, transparency and accountability.

    CNBC's Michelle Caruso-Cabrera reports on China's selection of new leaders to meet public calls for better government and give the economy a boost.

    The congress will end with the unveiling of the new leadership. Yet in spite of acres of fevered analysis from China-watchers, the reality is that we know virtually nothing about what Xi Jinping thinks about anything, let alone the secretive process by which he was selected.

    Is he another grey and cautious techocrat or a closet reformer? Take your pick. We can all be experts in the face of the party's secrecy.

    Embassy ballots give Chinese a taste of democracy ahead of power transfer

    On paper at least the Communist Party has 82 million members, but only a tiny clique make the real decisions, and there is an enormous gulf -- vast and growing -- between them and the people it is supposed to represent, a gulf filled increasingly with cynicism and distrust.

    Peter Parks / AFP - Getty Images

    President Hu Jintao, seen on a television in a motorcycle repair shop in Shanghai, called for stepped-up political reform and a revamped economic model as the Communist Party opened a historic congress to usher in a new slate of leaders.

    China has changed dramatically since the party last changed its leaders a decade ago -- from the economy to the thriving social media that's such a thorn in the side of the leadership, and where the timing of the leadership change, so soon after the raucous U.S. election has provoked many an uncomfortable (for the party) comparison.

    The dynamism elsewhere in China is in stark contrast with the ossified spectacle on display this week in the Great Hall. Those carrier pigeons are the least of the party’s problems.

     

    54 comments

    Meanwhile, America has more laws governing its citizens than China... or any other country in the world, for that matter. Meanwhile, America spies on its own citizens, and saying the wrong thing online could bring the feds knocking at your door in the middle of the night. Meanwhile, Americans cluck  …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, congress, hu-jintao, communist, featured, xi-jinping, ian-williams, commentid-featured
  • 19
    Oct
    2012
    8:30am, EDT

    US and China: A tale of two leadership styles

    Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

    By Ed Flanagan, NBC News

    BEIJING - While the candidates are scrutinized and skewered by the media in the U.S., China's new leader Xi Jinping remains a man of mystery among his citizens. NBC's Ian Williams was in Beijing this week, walking, cycling and driving through the streets of the capital to find out just what Beijingers know about the man who is slated to become China's next President.

    2 comments

    US and China: A tale of two leadership styles For China, it's way too much and for the US, none at all.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, cpc, presidential-elections, xi-jinping, ian-williams
  • 3
    Sep
    2012
    11:39pm, EDT

    Diving deep into the secrets of the Great Wall

    Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

    By Ed Flanagan, NBC News

    BEIJING - The Great Wall of China is one of the world's most famous landmarks, but much of it is still being explored. NBC's Ian Williams joined noted Great Wall historian, William Lindesay and Steven Schwankert of SinoScuba to take a unique look at one hidden section of the wall, diving down into a vast lake that submerged the wall when an entire valley was flooded decades ago.

     

    2 comments

    The building of the Great Wall is one of the worst human tragedies because it was constructed by forced labor. Thousands died under the brutal conditions imposed on them by the Chinese rulers. Similarly with the building of St. Petersburg, Russia. An estimated twenty-five thousand serfs died from th …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, today-show, great-wall, ian-williams
  • 13
    Jul
    2012
    2:08pm, EDT

    The ghosts that haunt China's economic landscape

    Daniel Berehulak / Getty Images file

    Chinese newlyweds pose for wedding photographs near to the Thames Town Church in Thames Town on November 19, 2010 in Songjiang, China.

    By Ian Williams, NBC News

    SHANGHAI, China -- It can take two or three hours to drive from bustling Shanghai to the sleepy streets of Thames Town, a new housing development built in the style of an English village complete with quaint pubs, red telephone boxes and statues of Harry Potter and James Bond. There's even an Anglican Church, though not a functioning one.

    All that's missing are the people.

    Thames Town was completed in 2006, cost a billion dollars to build, and was designed as home for 10,000 people. But shops and restaurants are boarded up, their doors chained.


    Thames Town is one of the more bizarre examples of the madness of a construction frenzy and real estate bubble that has left the country with an estimated sixty four million empty homes. It was fuelled by easy money and rapidly rising prices.

    Some economists see it as the biggest property bubble of all time - entire ghost cities built on speculation.

    China reports slowest growth rate in 3 years

    "Empty roads, empty buildings, empty neighborhoods, empty cities - all over China," says Gillem Tulloch, Managing Director of Forensic Asia, who has traced the spread of the ghosts using Google Earth.

    When I last visited his Hong Kong office, we sat in front of a big computer screen on which he zoomed in on city after city, row upon row of empty apartment blocks, lining deserted roads. All have what look like government buildings, museums and universities - the amenities of modern cities, but few cars or people to be seen.

    By China's own estimate, there are twenty new cities being built each year. One recent housing development was designed to look like a village in Austria.

    And it isn't just homes that lie empty: In the southern city of Dongguan, the New South China Mall, once touted as the world's largest, has been ninety nine per cent empty since it opened in in 2005 – although gondolas are still at hand to offer visitors a cruise down its Venetian-style canals.

    More recently, property prices have started to fall after the government took belated measures to end speculation. In some places, construction has slowed or ground to a halt. Construction equipment companies are struggling and there are reports of construction workers being laid off.


    Follow @msnbc_world

    The problem for the Chinese government is that construction is a major component of GDP. Wasteful and mad though it may seem to outsiders, it has helped pump up growth figures, particularly after the 2008 financial crises, when the Chinese government injected into the economy a stimulus worth nearly US$700 billion. Much of that money went straight to those ghost towns.

    Local government has come to rely on rising land prices for its funding, and local authorities have run up huge property-related debts. Nobody quite knows how exposed China's banks might be.

    This is the background against which today's GDP figures should be seen. A lot of economists think the figures are pretty dodgy, and don't properly reflect the reality on the ground, but it’s still a significant slowdown by Chinese standards. And it poses a big dilemma for the government.

    More savvy ministers know that property represents a dangerous bubble, and wants prices to fall further. They also know that the Chinese economy needs changing - re-balancing in economist-speak - away from wasteful construction projects and exports and today's domestic demand. That will also do a big favor to the world economy.

    But with growth dipping below the psychologically important eight per cent level, and the communist party credibility on the line, there'll be a real temptation to open the financial taps again to boost the growth figures. The main impact of that will be to keep Gillen Tulloch busy as he looks at yet more ghost towns, delaying the day of reckoning for China’s economy.

    More world news from msnbc.com and NBC News:

    • Briton charged with fraud over bomb detectors
    • China offers bounty for piranhas, dead or alive
    • Ex-pats rush to aid Syrian students abroad
    • Avalanche kills at least 9 in French Alps
    • North Korea mystery woman: A possible new first lady?

    Follow World News on msnbc.com on Twitter and Facebook

     

    43 comments

    Well, at least they aren't spending all of that American money on weapons. Thanks again corporate America! You commit treason, make a bunch of $, thousands of Americans loos their jobs, and now China has plenty of disposable income. People should hang for it.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, economy, world, nbc, shanghai, featured, nighty-news, ian-williams
  • 28
    Nov
    2011
    1:07pm, EST

    Double amputee battles triathlon and wins silver

    By Ian Williams, NBC News Correspondent

    BEIJING – The first time I met Andre Kajlich he was dodging Beijing traffic – in a racing wheelchair.  

    "Oh yeah, it was good out there," he told me, a huge smile on his face. "You should have seen the look I got from the bus driver."

    Kajlich had traveled from his Seattle home to the Chinese capital to take part in the world championship of one of the world's most demanding sports – the paratriathlon. And taking his wheelchair for a spin on the highway was just one of his ways of tuning up.

    Kajlich is a double amputee. When he lost his legs in a subway accident eight years ago, doctors doubted he would ever walk again – even with prosthetics. But he was determined to prove them wrong.

    "No matter what, I was going to do everything I could do," he said. And entering the grueling world of the triathlon is just his latest challenge, winning a place in the Beijing contest after just one year in the sport.


    "It gives you perspective on what you are capable of, really of what everybody's capable of," he told me. "You can choose what you want to do, and once you make up your mind you are going to get there no matter what it takes."

    Ian Williams / NBC News

    Andre Kajlich at the triathlon venue in Beijing.

    Inspiring others
    It's an inspirational message he's been taking to other young American amputees. He and his sister Bianca, an actress,  are counselors at the annual Paddy Rosebach youth camp, a summer gathering for 10- to 17-year-old amputees, which was held this year in Clarksville, Ohio.

    "I try to get them to look at their goals and to focus on those and to make up their minds, make the same choices I did, that you are going to get there no matter what, and try to put the other stuff aside."

    And he told me that he in turn had found the young amputees a huge inspiration as he prepared for Beijing.

    The triathlon took place around (and in) the Ming Tombs Reservoir at the foot of the mountains that rise to the north of Beijing. It had been the triathlon venue during the 2008 Olympics.

    Ian Williams / NBC News

    Andre Kajlich snaps a photo with a fan on China's Great Wall of China.

    There were nine contestants in Kajlich's category. "It's going to take a special effort from me," he said.

    The first part of the race was a half-mile swim that left him in fourth place, followed by a quick change to his hand bike, where he made up a further place over the twelve mile course. The final three miles were in racing wheelchairs, where Kajlich clawed back another place - finishing second. It was a silver medal for the paratriathlon rookie.

    His smile after the race was broader than ever: "How about that? Dude, I was just knocking them down."

    A celeb on the Great Wall

    On his last day in Beijing we traveled with Kajlich to the Great Wall of China, where he was determined to climb amid the holiday crowds along some of the steep sections that are tough enough at the best of times.

    But it didn't surprise me by then. This is one very determined young man, and he became an instant celebrity. At one point, people were lining up to shake his hand and have their photographs taken with him.

    Ian Williams / NBC News

    The Great Wall of China was packed with tourists the day Andre Kajlich visited.

    There is a tendency in China for people to stare at those who are different. Kajlich was wearing shorts, his prosthetic legs clearly showing. I asked him whether all the attention bothered him. Not at all, he said.

    "They're nice about it. They're not poking fun at me or anything,” he said.

    Then came another request for a photo. "Send me a copy," he said. "Maybe one day I'll see you in Seattle."

    At this point I was getting a bit worried about how far we'd come and suggested we make our way back. I was afraid he might be getting tired, but he wasn't through yet.

    "One of the reason I made up my mind to use the prosthetics was to get around in places like this," he said.

    We did take a break though, because by then I was the one wanting to pause for breath. I asked him what he planned next. Maybe skiing, maybe bobsledding, he said. "There are so many things I'd like to get out there and try and do. I'll do them. I'll figure a way."

    As if to stress that point, he'd gone on after Beijing to Kona, Hawaii to compete in the Ironman World Championships, where he beat his own time goals, and came second in his division.

    "I've made it through my first Ironman," he told me in an e-mail. "And did pretty well."

    And having spent some time with Kajlich I wouldn't have expected anything less.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: double-amputee, ian-williams, paratriathlon, andre-kajlich
  • 19
    Sep
    2011
    6:38pm, EDT

    China's soaring costs could help American jobs

    There is now evidence that amid soaring Chinese costs, jobs are beginning to move back to the United States. NBC's Ian Williams has this report from Dongguan, Southern China - an area once dubbed the workshop of the world.

    By Ian Williams, NBC New Correspondent

    DONGGUAN, China – For Bill Green it was more than just a routine visit to his Dongguan factory.

    The thuds, bangs and sparks of the factory floor were the same; the metal cut, twisted and welded in the usual shower of sparks. It had all become very familiar from five years of visiting factories in China, outsourcing his production of industrial cabinets, chasing lower costs.

    For years he had generally been happy with the results, but no longer.

    "If they don't sand the stuff down, that will come back through the damned paint and we'll have an issue here," he said, running his finger along the edge of one unfinished cabinet.

    Later, hunched over a laptop, the factory boss at his side, his frustration came pouring out.

    "This is unacceptable, we can't have this," he complained. "This is rust coming out from here."

    The factory boss looked to his chief engineer who became defensive, "We can't fix every problem. It takes too much manpower," he complained.

    The boss said Green was being too demanding.

    "None of these problems are hard to fix," Green shot back. "We work to these standards all the time in the United States."


    Green owns a metal-processing factory in Mobile, Ala., where his workforce shrunk from 60 to just 25 as more work, on cabinets and also on lamps, was outsourced to China.

    But after this trip he made a decision – to bring at least some of that work back home.

    "Everybody knew you could get anything made in China, and make money on it back in the United States. But things are changing," he told me later. "Prices are going up, and its making it harder to import stuff from here."

    More than that, attitudes were changing. "Used to be when you'd come over here everyone wanted your business. Now it’s harder and harder to get them to cooperate with you."

    So Green is planning to shift the final assembly of cabinets back to Alabama, and will divide much of the lamp production between India and the U.S.

    Is China as the ‘world’s factory’ done?
    The area Green was visiting, around Dongguan in southern China, has been called the workshop of the world, China's export powerhouse.

    There are tens of thousands of factories, sprawling for miles from the Hong Kong border, their stained peach and white tiled walls lining the motorways. Laundry hangs in the windows of the adjacent dormitories that have been home to millions of migrant workers, the foot-soldiers of China's export machine.

    Tao Dong, chief Asia economist for Credit Suisse in Hong Kong, tells NBC's Ian Williams that, due to soaring labor costs, many Chinese exporters are turning down orders from Europe and the United States. "China as the world factory, the best time is behind us," he said.

    For 17 years, Tao Dong, now chief Asia economist with Credit Suisse, has been covering its breakneck growth. But when I met him in Hong Kong recently, he told me, "China as the world factory, the best time is behind us."

    Labor costs are soaring by 40 percent a year, as migrant workers are becoming pickier, since there are more job opportunities at home. Also China's one-child policy means there is no longer such a huge pool of young, dexterous workers. Bank lending is tightening and China's currency is also appreciating by around 6 percent a year against the U.S. dollar, not quickly enough for US and European policymakers, but sufficient for factories on low margins to feel the pain.

    "This is the first time I've seen so many Chinese exporters collectively turning down orders from the U.S., from Europe," Dong told me. "They're bleeding," he said. "Costs are rising so much. They are just not profitable. They are actually dying."

    As Green discovered, it wasn't the costs alone. Labor shortages, and what he suspected to be corner-cutting by the factories were impacting quality, and he found himself paying as much to have a cabinets put right in the U.S., as he was paying for the original product in China.

    "We've reached a point where the risks are not worth the rewards," he told me.

    ‘Poor quality is expensive’
    Green's agent in Dongguan is Ben Schwall, a veteran import-export man, and one of the most astute observers of the local economic scene as you could hope to meet. He's become a regular point of call when I visit the area, and this time Schwall told me his job was becoming much more complicated.

    Factories are responding to cost pressures by demanding bigger orders or larger down payments, he told me, or abandoning exports and looking to the growing domestic market.

    "A lot of the problems we have now are delivery times and the cutting of corners. It's more than just price. All these things end up having a cost, though. Poor quality is expensive, angry customers are expensive. Missed shipments are expensive,” said Schwall.

    But he thinks it’s too early to write an obituary for China Inc. The supply chain is still second to none, he said, and the latest trade figures show exports from China overall still to be strong.

    That said, Schwall's just got himself a five-year visa for India. "I'm also planning to go to Vietnam in the near future to look at some factories. Offshoring, outsourcing, no longer means just China. There are other places we need to look, and, yes, there's also the
    American solution of bringing some products back to the U.S.”

    Exporting U.S. goods to China?
    Before he returned to Alabama, Green was faced with an intriguing offer.

    One factory boss said he wanted to re-orientate his production of lamps towards China's domestic market. "We've got a lot of rich people now," he said, "and we want to offer them a complete American flavor." He explained that middle-class Chinese associated American products with higher quality, and asked whether Green would work with him to bring U.S.-style lamps to the Chinese market.

    The proposal was short on detail, but Green found it tantalizing all the same. "It's a fantastic idea," he said. "I didn't realize the market was ready at this point. We are going to pioneer it."

    Back at my hotel, there was an unusual sight from my 26th-floor window. I could actually see the factories of Dongguan, sprawling for miles below me. I'd never seen it so clear. Usually it’s just a smudge through a thick miasma that hangs over the factories.

    The lobby too was different, almost empty. Usually it’s packed with buyers from every corner of the planet on their phones and iPods, waiting to be whisked away to factories by a fleet of mini-buses. The pianist was still there half way up a spiral staircase, but serenading just two or three lonely buyers beneath the lobby's artificial palm trees.

    Further evidence of a slowdown at the factories? Schwall warned me not to read too much into it. The summer's always quieter. The Christmas buyers hadn't yet arrived.

    But something was certainly changing. "Five years ago it was a no-brainer. If you wanted variety and low costs on a whole range of goods, you'd come here. Now it’s a lot more complicated," Schwall told me.

    For American business people like Green, it’s no longer a one way street. There are new opportunities. And Green returned to Alabama preparing for the first time in years to create new jobs – in America. 

    505 comments

    THANK YOU Mr. Bill Green for bringing jobs back to AMERICA. I did catch that a portion of the lamp business may go to India...PLEASE...bring all your business back and lets only hope that more of CORPORATE AMERICA will follow your lead and do the same.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: china, jobs, featured, ian-williams
Older posts

Browse

  • china,
  • featured,
  • ed-flanagan,
  • adrienne-mong,
  • bo-gu,
  • world-news,
  • beijing,
  • human-rights,
  • eric-baculinao,
  • north-korea,
  • chen-guangcheng,
  • u-s,
  • economy,
  • ai-weiwei,
  • asia,
  • ian-williams,
  • bo-xilai,
  • environment,
  • tibet,
  • communist-party,
  • hong-kong,
  • xi-jinping,
  • shanghai,
  • behind-the-wall,
  • one-child-policy,
  • internet,
  • censorship,
  • gu-kailai,
  • protest,
  • world,
  • updated,
  • weibo,
  • asia-pacific,
  • activist,
  • us,
  • hacking,
  • apple,
  • pollution,
  • taiwan,
  • military,
  • wen-jiabao,
  • corruption,
  • scandal
Also
Advertise | AdChoices

Behind The Wall

Behind the Wall provides a dynamic look at China by examining news events and trends – both big and small – from NBC News correspondents and producers. Learn about China's developing economy, politics and the cultural trends that move its 1.3 billion people.

Ed Flanagan

is a Beijing-based producer for NBC News. In China since 2005, he has been a part of the team's China as well as regional news coverage.

Ed Flanagan Blogroll

  • Michael Pettis
  • James Fallows
  • China Law Blog
  • Silicon Hutong
  • Sinica Podcasts
  • China Digital Times
  • The China Beat
  • China Geeks
  • NBC World Blog
  • China Hush

Archives

  • 2013
    • May (7)
    • April (7)
    • March (11)
    • February (16)
    • January (9)
  • 2012
    • December (6)
    • November (15)
    • October (12)
    • September (18)
    • August (11)
    • July (13)
    • June (12)
    • May (22)
    • April (17)
    • March (16)
    • February (20)
    • January (13)
  • 2011
    • December (13)
    • November (17)
    • October (10)
    • September (13)
    • August (13)
    • July (14)
    • June (21)
    • May (12)
    • April (10)
    • March (12)
    • February (22)
    • January (18)
  • 2010
    • December (20)
    • November (36)
    • October (6)
    • September (3)
    • August (2)
    • July (4)

Most Commented

  • Will China mediate the Israeli-Palestinian peace process? (319)
  • Chinese spooked by food scandals take action - by growing it themselves (44)
  • 'Get out': Over 1,000 take to the streets in China to protest oil refinery (38)

Other blogs

  • Daily Nightly
  • The Maddow Blog
  • The Last Word
  • Hardblogger
  • First Read
  • World Blog
  • Field Notes
  • Inside Dateline
  • Behind the Wall
  • The Ed Show
  • Morning Joe
  • Daily Rundown

NBCNews.com top stories

3147,10
© 2013 NBCNews.com
  • World news on NBCNews.com
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Help
  • Site map
  • Careers
  • Closed captioning
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertise