• Chinese expert: Drought is a 'warning signal'

    ChinaFotoPress/Getty Images

    A fishing boat runs aground on grass at Poyang Lake in Jiujiang, Jiangxi Province, China on Saturday. The Yangtze river is suffering from a severe drought, with the lowest level of rainfall in 5 decades.

    By Eric Baculinao, NBC News’ Beijing Bureau Chief

    BEIJING – “Oh waters of Honghu Lake, wave after wave. The fishermen live ever better, year after year…” are the happy lines from a popular folk song sung by communities in Hubei province who have depended on the vast lake for their economic sustenance for centuries. But now the lake is drying up in what many are calling the worst drought in more than 50 years and the song may not be heard for quite some time.   

    In the neighboring province of Jiangxi, fishing boats sit eerily stranded on grassland that was once the bed of Poyang Lake, China’s largest fresh water lake, a dramatic scene that attests to the severity of south China’s 200-day drought. 

    Already, the lack of rainfall and water shortages have affected 35 million people in five provinces, with some 4.2 million directly threatened by lack of drinking water, prompting authorities to adopt emergency rationing and distribution of water. 

    The implications of the drought in southern China, traditionally a region with abundant water resources, have not been lost on Ma Jun, China’s leading environmentalist who has focused on the fragility of the water resource system of China for years. 
    “It is a new warning signal,” said Ma, the author of “China’s Water Crisis.”


    Time to re-examine China’s water policy
    Ma’s seminal book is widely acknowledged as the most comprehensive and authoritative documentation of the enormous challenges facing China’s water resources. Many observers have likened Ma’s 1999 book to Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring,” which has been credited for launching environmental movement in the U.S., and believe it has done the same thing in China.  
     
    “This drought tells us that water scarcity does not only exist in north China, but increasingly south China is also facing water challenges,” Ma told NBC News. “It is a new warning signal because it shows the south is no longer a store with unlimited water supply.”

    He suggested China needs to re-examine its long-term water strategy and propensity for mega-projects, including the $62 billion South-North Water Diversion Project that would transfer nearly 36 billion cubic meters of water every year from China’s Yangtze River Basin and ship it to the arid north.

    The gigantic water diversion project, which started in 2002 and is planned for completion in 2050, will be China’s greatest engineering project after the Great Wall, and will cost more than twice as much as the Three Gorges Dam, the world’s biggest dam.  

    DAVID GRAY / Reuters

    A farmer's hat is seen on a dried-up portion of an irrigation canal leading from Honghu Lake, as a fisherman manoeuvres his boat with a pole on the canal near Honghu city in central China's Hubei province on Sunday.

    “We were going to divert [this] large volume of water from the Yangtze River to support north China, but now we are encountering this drought in south China, which is a warning bell for us,” Ma said.

    Is the Three Gorges Dam a culprit?
    For Ma, however, the more immediate issue is the possible role of the Three Gorges Dam, the world’s largest hydroelectric project, in the current drying up of lakes and rivers in the south China region. “The Yangtze River and the lakes downstream have quite a delicate relationship,” he said, that might have been upset by the dam’s construction.

    “These great lakes connected with the Yangtze River would take flood and excessive waters from the Yangtze during the rainy season, and will feed water into the Yangtze during the dry season, but now things have changed with the Three Gorges Dam,” he said, arguing that the dam has reduced the amount of water available in the lake areas.

    “With lesser water running from the Yangtze into the lakes, the lakes will be losing water over time,” he added, citing the progressive shrinking of south China’s great lakes.

    Referring to the flow of water from the dam to refill the lower Yangtze rivers and lakes during the dry season, he said it is “helpful in theory,” but not in practice. 

    More alarming, according to Ma, is the plan to build 12 more dams on the Yangtze River and tributaries, with a combined capacity larger than the Three Gorges Dam. “It is time to review the negative impact of the Three Gorges Dam,” he said.

    Meanwhile, Ma’s concerns have recently been echoed by the government which in an unprecedented statement admitted that while the Three Gorges Dam has been successful, it has also created “urgent” environmental, geological and economic problems.

    Related links:

    Drought parches China's 'land of fish and rice'

    China confronts raft of problems at Three Gorges
     
    Researcher Xu Yuan contributed to this report.

  • Are China & North Korea happier than America?

    Courtesy Chaoxian.com.cn

    An alleged "Global Happiness Index" put out by North Korean television ranked the Chinese as the happiest people in the world. They were followed by North Korea, Cuba, Iran and Venezuela respectfully. The United States came in last.

    BEIJING – "Are you happy?" is a question that many in China have been asking themselves with increasing frequency in recent years. This week North Korea emphatically answered that question for them: “Yes, yes, you are.”

    A report floating around China’s websphere alleges that North Korea’s Chosun Central Television recently released a global happiness index compiled by North Korean researchers. Perhaps not surprisingly, it found China the happiest place in the world, with a perfect score of 100 points. Just two points behind, in second place, was North Korea; Cuba came in third with a rating of 93.

    It has been difficult to find the full list online in Chinese media (usually a good source for North Korean news).
    But the screen grab to the right from a Chinese website, Chaoxian, shows the supposed line-up. North Korea’s rival, South Korea, didn't fair too well, it scored just 18 points to come in at 152. And the “American Empire” was dead last in the rankings at number 203 with a measly two points.

    Iran and Venezuela were the only other nations whose listing were shown by Chaoxian, coming in fourth and fifth respectively.

    Criteria for the index ratings were not available nor was the source of the story immediately identifiable.

    The results have been widely discussed in the Chinese websphere, drawing a great deal of amusement, skepticism and sarcasm. 

    On Mop, a popular Chinese online forum, one comment noted that the “North Koreans learned their technique of bluffing from the Chinese." While another jokingly pleaded, “Please send me to the U.S. so I can suffer too."

    For China, the results come at a time when national happiness has become a contentious issue. Municipal governments on the mainland have begun measuring the happiness of their people and nearly a dozen national polls have been conducted recently. 

    The need to quantify and to demonstrate increasing happiness in China has become a contentious issue among China-watchers as they debate whether the numbers are meant to further illustrate the ruling Communist Party’s continued efforts to nurture a “harmonious society” or whether these happiness studies will eventually be used to prop up the government when the country’s long anticipated economic slowdown comes.

    Regardless of their intentions, the question of personal happiness is one that has struck a chord with many Chinese who have quickly moved up the social and economic ladder through higher paying jobs and increased educational opportunities.

    For this week, though, China can smile and know that through at least one measure, they are the happiest people in the world.

    Certainly happier, at least, than the estimated 19,000 young North Korean university graduates who earlier this week volunteered in the name of the proletarian paradise to work “laborious jobs in different economic sectors in the DPRK.”

    Hat tip to Shanghaiist for the link.

  • It's official: the Great Leader was in China

    /

    China's President Hu Jintao and North Korean leader Kim Jong-il shake hands at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on Thursday. The photo was distributed by China's official Xinhua News Agency Thursday.

    BEIJING--This week saw what appeared to be a re-injection of warmth and energy in relations between two longtime ideological allies with a shared history of fighting side by side in war.

    No.  Not that “special relationship” between the U.S. and U.K.

    That other one, between North Korea and China.

    In the past few days, we have been treated to the pomp and circumstance of President Barack Obama’s visit to Britain—including a Guard of Honor inspection at Buckingham Palace, a state banquet hosted by the Queen, an address to both Houses of Parliament, and dissection within the British media about how their country is back in America’s good graces.

    Even China’s 24-hour state-run news channel, CCTV13, devoted significant minutes to covering Obama’s trip and the bond between the two nations—now known as the “essential” relationship.

    Contrast that with the coverage of Kim Jong-il’s visit to China this week, which has been virtually nonexistent.

    Well, okay, it’s existed, but was essentially unconfirmed until it was over.


    Early confirmation of a sort did come from a surprising corner. During a summit with his Japanese and South Korean counterparts in Japan last weekend, Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao mentioned his government had invited Kim to visit “to understand the Chinese development and use it for their own development.”

    However, the Chinese Foreign Ministry has stuck to its usual line, refusing to comment on the visit.

    Just about the only news outlets that have confidently reported the North Korean leader’s trip through China via his special armored train (he doesn't like to fly) have been the South Korean and Japanese ones. 

    Although grainy sightings of Kim in Jiangsu Province have popped up online, reporters for most other news organizations stuck to using words like “reportedly” and “allegedly” in covering the story.

    Even the Chinese government-run Global Times had resorted to quoting other media for its coverage, explaining that, as a rule, officials from both countries don’t comment on rumors or reports of Kim’s visits as they’re in progress.   

    However, by late Thursday, China's state broadcaster CCTV and Xinhua finally confirmed the visit  -- which was seen as an indication that it was over since neither Beijing nor Pyongyang report Kim's visits until after he returns to North Korea.

    Among the highlights of Kim’s alleged visit were: tours of factories, an industrial park, and a shopping center; meetings with Wen and President Hu Jintao; and a visit to the Zhongguancun tech corridor in western Beijing. 

    Pictures, of course, have yet to emerge of the Dear Leader looking at any of these sights. China's official Xinhua News Agency only released the photo of Kim with Hu, seen above, Thursday.

    And while some observers have speculated on the reason for Kim's visit (food aid? tips on how to set up a market economy?), there's been plenty more guessing about the identity of a woman in his traveling entourage (wife? translator? the power behind the man?).

    It’s believed Kim is already back in North Korea's capital, Pyongyang.  

    Entertaining related link: Kim Jong Il looking at things  

  • China cracks down on food safety

    A rash of food safety scandals in the Chinese media has consumers on edge, but the government says it's just a sign they're cracking down. NBC's Adrienne Mong reports from Beijing.

  • Pakistan looks east to 'good friend' China

    DAVID GRAY / Reuters

    A Pakistan national flag flies alongside a Chinese national flag in front of the portrait of Chairman Mao Zedong on Beijing's Tiananmen Square during Pakistan Prime Minister Gilani's visit to China.

    By Ian Williams, NBC News Correspondent

    ISLAMABAD, Pakistan – At breakfast at my hotel I was having trouble with the cornflake dispenser. It was one of those tall cylindrical containers with a lever at the bottom that needed to be turned for the cornflakes to tumble out, only the lever was stuck. I gave up in frustration and almost walked into a young woman who'd been observing my dismal efforts.

    "Dui Bu Qui," (“excuse me”), she said, addressing me in Mandarin, before simply opening the top of the container and ladling out her cornflakes.

    She then returned to a table of what looked to me like Chinese businessmen. She was by far the smartest-dressed at the table, the translator I assumed, while the men – ruddy faced, a bit rough around the edges, and looking a little uncomfortable in dark suits and ties – were fairly typical of the traders or small town entrepreneurs I'm more familiar with on trips to provincial China.

    I looked further around the restaurant. There were several more tables of what looked to me like Chinese businessmen, while at the back, more discretely seated, was a more polished group, Chinese diplomats or bankers perhaps, pouring over some documents. (Possibly the latest photos of the American stealth helicopter downed in the Osama bin Laden raid, one colleague mischievously suggested. The Chinese military is allegedly anxious to get a look at the plans for the sophisticated chopper that was capable of evading radar detection).

    The reason I mention this is because this restaurant, in one of Islamabad's best and most secure hotels, has always been an anthropologists dream.

    At any one time the scene provides a wonderful insight into what's going on, who's up and who's down in turbulent Pakistan. Journalists, diplomats, business people and spooks rub shoulders around the buffet table with Pakistani government officials and bearded frontier tribesmen in flowing robes.


    On a recent morning, there were several tattooed Western men with shaven heads and bull-necks, some sort of security for one of the aforementioned I assumed, for whom "low-key" was clearly not part of the training.

    China, Pakistan’s ‘all-weather friend’
    It’s been like this over the many years I've been coming to Pakistan, and staying at this hotel, but I've never seen so many Chinese at the breakfast buffet.

    One look at the newspapers lying around the restaurant, and it’s easy to see why the Chinese are so welcome here.

    Jason Lee / AP

    Pakistani Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani, left, is welcomed by Chinese President Hu Jintao for a meeting at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on Friday.

    "China urges US to respect Pak sovereignty," headlined Pakistan’s Dawn newspaper Thursday. While the Express Tribune declared: "China endorses Pakistan's response to US raid."

    There has been much Pakistani praise of their "all-weather friend" in Beijing.

    Pakistan's Prime Minister Syed Yousuf Raza Gilani has been in Beijing this week and just clinched a deal in which China will provide Pakistan with 50 fighter jets to the tune of $20-25 million a pop. 

    The visit was organized some time back, but China has sought to maximize its diplomatic advantage following Pakistan's humiliation over the killing of Osama Bin Laden, and the subsequent crisis in U.S.-Pakistan relations.

    "China and Pakistan will remain forever good neighbors, good friends, good partners and good brothers," according to the Chinese Prime Minister, Wen Jiabao, quoted approvingly in newspapers here.

    The authorities in Punjab Province have even declared they will no longer accept aid from the U.S., but only from friends who do no attach strings, read China.

    Of course China and Pakistan have long been close, with Beijing allegedly helping in the development of Pakistan's nuclear weapon program, but it has only been more recently that the economic relationship has really taken off. China is pouring cash into Pakistan's infrastructure and natural resources, and in a December visit the Chinese prime minister announced billions of dollars of proposed investments.

    No wonder the crowds around that buffet are looking increasingly Chinese.

    Western diplomats, watching from their corner of the restaurant, seemed remarkably relaxed about the budding friendship between the two regional neighbors.

    Whatever diplomatic advantage it may be seeking this week, China has welcomed the death of Bin Laden, and has every reason itself to be concerned about Islamic militancy across the mountains from its own Muslim areas. Western diplomats believe its private message to Gilani is likely to have been very different from the public platitudes.

    And Chinese economic assistance can be double-edged.

    Investment is primarily motivated by China's hunger for raw materials, and it is frequently accompanied by Chinese labor. Trade between the two countries is also heavily skewed in China's favor. Pakistani manufacturers cannot compete with the cheap Chinese goods flooding Pakistan's markets, leading traders to frequently grumble about quality.

    Back at the breakfast buffet, the young woman who I'd (almost) bumped into at the cornflake dispenser, rose to leave with her entourage. She and a colleague carried between them a heavy bag that appeared to contain two Chinese tea sets – gifts, I assumed, for their would-be business partners in a country that for the moment needs every friend it can get.

  • New PLA video game pits Chinese against U.S. soldiers

    CCTV, China's state TV, reports on the new PLA-developed video game.

    BEIJING – In 2005, I was deeply engaged in an extended military campaign on battlefields across China. Thousands of Chinese and Americans fell each day, but the only real casualty suffered was my bruised ego as I was easily picked off time and again in a blaze of glory playing the videogame, Battlefield 2.

    Battlefield 2, a popular first-person multiplayer shooter released that year, pitted U.S. Marines, Chinese forces and a fictional Middle Eastern Coalition against each other in imaginary locations around the world.

    The game’s Chinese maps and scenarios were incredibly popular among Chinese players who took great pleasure in blasting me and countless others with a variety of different weapons regardless of whether my character was wearing a Chinese or American uniform.

    Which is why it is surprising to see the recent release of Glorious Mission (also known as, Mission of Honor), a military simulation jointly developed by the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) and Chinese software developer, Giant Interactive Group. It has generated waves in the U.S. not for its graphics or game play – but for the fact that American soldiers are the main adversary.


    Objections don't appear to be focused on the game's existence. After all, the U.S. military is heavily invested in its own acclaimed military training and recruitment game, America’s Armybut it features a generic enemy, so as not to offend anyone.

    Rather, the concern is that the game, which was ostensibly developed as a training tool for the PLA, makes American solders and equipment the enemy combatant and could lead young, impressionable trainees to believe that the United States is the enemy.

    There are indeed legitimate concerns that some nationalist elements in the PLA do view conflict with the United States as inevitable. However, in the case of Glorious Mission, it seems unlikely that one simulation could dramatically alter the thinking of PLA enlisted men. After all, the generation of soldiers that Glorious Mission is geared towards has already been exposed to a wide variety of online games that pit players against a whole host of enemies ranging from the real to the ridiculous.

    CCTV

    Designed by the People's Liberation Army and a Chinese gaming company, Glorious Mission is a military simulation game intended for training purposes.

    Take a trip to any Internet café or arcade around China and the one thing that can quickly be concluded is that when it comes to video games, teenagers playing first-person shooters don’t particularly care who or what they are shooting at, as long as they are shooting at something.

    Online dominance                 
    Perhaps what should be of greater concern to American tech insiders is the apparent smoothness of the graphics and game play of Glorious Mission.

    The successful development of Glorious Mission represents not just a small step forward by the PLA towards creating an American style “virtual army experience,” but also the Chinese gaming industry’s noticeable move up the technological food chain.

    In the last few years there has been an explosion in online gaming in China, fueled by the rise of countless Chinese gaming companies. In 2010 alone, China's online gaming market raked in 32.37 billion Yuan (approximately $4.9 billion) – a 26.3 percent increase over 2009.

    With over 76 million online game players in China and a business model that sensibly caters to young gamers’ wallets through low-cost games and cheap add-ons, it is no small wonder that the country has quickly risen to become the largest online gaming market, expected to be valued in excess of $8 billion by 2014.

    Meanwhile, as U.S. gaming companies have largely struggled to sell their products in China, Chinese companies are beginning to make in-roads in the U.S. market. Earlier this year, China’s largest Internet company, Tencent Holdings, bought a majority share of American gaming company Riot Games Inc. for more than $350 million.

  • Jilted bride saved in suicide drama

    A jilted bride-to-be was dragged to safety after threatening to leap from a seventh-story window after her fiancé married another woman, Reuters reported. Watch video in new window.

    China Daily via Reuters

    A 22-year-old woman in a wedding gown is grabbed by Guo Zhongfan, a local community officer, as she attempts to kill herself by jumping out of a seven-story residential building in Changchun, Jilin province, China on May 17. According to local media, the woman tried to commit suicide after her boyfriend of four years broke up with her, just as they were making plans to get married. The woman did not sustain any injuries during the incident.

    Dressed in her wedding gown, a college student identified only as Miss Li climbed out on the window ledge of the building in Changchun city in northeast China.

    According to local TV, the 22-year-old sobbed and swung her legs out the window for about an hour before police officers arrived.

    Li said she could not live with the fact her fiancé had left her and married another woman just days before their wedding, local TV said.

    China Daily via Reuters

    The woman sits on a windowsill before attempting to jump.

    Reuters reported that the woman lived on the fourth floor of the building but made her way to another apartment upstairs.

    As dozens of people looked on, authorities arrived at the seventh-floor dwelling determined to prevent Li from taking her own life.

    Television footage showed a local official named Guo Zhongfan holding Li by her neck and arms as she dangled above the street.

    China Daily via Reuters

    From left: Guo Zhongfan grabs hold of the woman; other people assist from below; the woman is pulled inside the building.

    Changchun Television said she pushed herself off the ledge before she was grabbed by Guo. A man in the apartment below assisted in the rescue by reaching out the window and pushing Li’s feet up.

    The crowd gathered below applauded Guo after the woman was pulled back inside.

    "I did what anyone would have done," Guo told reporters.

    Li was later taken to hospital.

    A community officer pulled a 22-year-old woman to safety after she threatened to jump out of a building in China because her boyfriend married another woman. TODAY.com's Dara Brown reports.

     

  • Adoption scandal exposed by muckraking Chinese journalists

    Bo Gu / NBC News

    Yang Libing (with his son) holds up a photo of his missing daughter, Yang Ling.

    GAOPING, HUNAN PROVINCE – Until this year, Yang Libing, whose daughter was taken from him by family planning authorities, would receive visits from one or two Chinese journalists every year.

    "They would come to interview me about my daughter," he recalled emphatically.  "But nothing ever came of those reports.  Still no one did anything."

    In 2005, family planning officials in Longhui County, Hunan Province, took away Yang's daughter, Yang Ling, when she was eleven months old.   They accused him of not registering her birth, thereby breaking the strict, nationwide one-child policy – even though she was his first and only offspring.

    The authorities sent his daughter off to an orphanage.  From there, Yang believes she was adopted by an American family, with the family planning officials receiving a few hundred dollars in return.

    Yang has not seen her since.

    "I wish I could tell her that I didn't give her away," he told NBC News in an interview at his spartan home in the mountains of Gaoping.  "It wasn't a case of not wanting her.  I didn't reject her."

    Caixin Century publishes report
    Yang's story has the hallmarks of a great tragedy, embodying many controversial issues that touch a raw nerve in China: local corruption, brutal enforcement of the one-child policy, the policy itself, child trafficking, and poverty.


    And yet, despite stories by local journalists and a long feature printed in the Los Angeles Times two years ago, his story never seemed to catch on.  

    Then last week, the highly respected independent Chinese weekly news magazine, Caixin Century, ran a 15,000-word investigative report that featured Yang and several other families in Gaoping whose children suffered the same fate.

    This time, the tale of baby-trafficking by corrupt family planning officials electrified China's media.  Even the state-run newspapers covered the story, some reporting that an official investigation was underway.

    Within a day of publication, teams of local and foreign journalists (including NBC News) began tramping into the lush, terraced hills of Longhui County, perhaps the poorest area in all in Hunan – which is already one of China's more impoverished provinces.
     
    So why did the story suddenly capture the media's attention now?

    An obvious reason is that Caixin has a sterling reputation for its investigative journalism.  Furthermore, the report was richly detailed and well-researched, the product of four years' long work.

    "A few years ago, the story was told very simply," said Shangguan Jiaoming, the Caixin reporter behind the Hunan story.  "My report includes a lot of detail and analysis."

    Moreover, Caixin is homegrown, i.e., its reporting is done by Chinese in Chinese.

    Bo Gu / NBC News

    Gaoping sits up in the mountains of Longhui County, Hunan Province.

    "It really shows that however much foreign correspondents report on China, unless a story gets picked up by domestic media here, there isn’t much...we can do to improve the lives of people here that we interview,” said Melissa Chan, the Beijing correspondent for al-Jazeera English.  (Just as it does in the Middle East, al-Jazeera has a reputation in China for moving quickly and aggressively to cover politically sensitive stories. Chan's report can be seen here.)

    Another reason is the growing popularity of microblogs like Sina.com's Weibo or Twitter.  Although the latter is blocked in China, it can be accessed via virtual private networks (VPNs) that bypass the firewall – a tool widely used by the same crop of intellectual and professional Chinese elites who comprise Caixin's readership.

    Through microblogs, news of the Caixin report spread like wildfire.  As with many stories of this nature, anything that survives Internet censors for even a few hours can gain traction and reach readers across the country.

    But there's another reason – one which might seem a bit surprising given the repressive trend of cracking down on dissidents, activists, and media (especially foreign) in China during recent months: good old-fashioned market competition. 

    "Since the mid-1990s, commercial media in [mainland] China has become much more competitive," said David Bandurski of the China Media Project at Hong Kong University.  There was no "media market" or "ad-driven publications" before then.  Much of that transformation came about because then-Premier Zhao Ziyang pushed for a more open, liberal press corps – one which would try to use public opinion to monitor political power rather than serve as a means to "marshal public opinion."

    The trend sustained itself even after Zhao was sacked from the Communist Party for supporting the students leading the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests.

    Some of the more remarkable stories broken by domestic Chinese reporters include the AIDS villages in Henan Province and the SARS crisis.  The former story, in particular, was reported a year before it appeared in Western media like the New York Times.

    China’s commercial media: driven and aggressive
    "The reality is that commercial media – as opposed to state-run media – has to sell to readers, they have to have a different look, a different appeal," continued Bandurski.

    As a result, the commercial news organizations command circulation figures enviable by publishers anywhere in the world.

    Although it has not been possible to audit circulation data, Bandurski reckons that, based on China Press Yearbook statistics, "In every case, if you look at the Party-run paper and the corresponding commercial spin-off in any region," the latter outstrips the former in terms of readership.

    Adrienne Mong / NBC News

    Villagers from Gaoping look at a copy of the Caixin Century.

    "For example, in Wuhan (a second-tier city with a long intellectual history), the commercial paper has 1, 2, or 3 million circulation," he said.  "No Party newspaper has a circulation like that."

    Among those that produce some of best, influential, tough, in-depth investigative reporting are Caixin and Beijing News in Beijing and the Southern group in Guangdong Province, which publishes Southern Daily and Southern Weekend. 

    These organizations constantly recalibrate their coverage, led by senior editors such as Hu Shuli at Caixin (an excellent profile of her ran in 2009 in The New Yorker), for example, who have a finely honed sixth sense for politics, for knowing when to push their agenda.

    One way in which the more aggressive Chinese commercial media outlets appear to escape being shut down is to adopt what Bandurski calls "the shouldering the door theory."  One publication knocks the door, then another, then another – the premise being that the government can't go after every organization all at once.

    "It's always the media pushing," said Bandurski.  "It's never the government loosening."

    Corrupt media, too
    Which is not to say that the Chinese press corps is made up of only hard-charging truth-seekers.

    Far from it.  Local journalists earn low salaries, all too often supplemented by the notorious "red envelopes" – cash gifts supplied by the subjects of their reporting – and other "perks."

    Our savvy driver from Hunan's capital of Changsha – with years of experience shuttling around local and foreign reporters – summed up what he’s seen.

    "When the foreign media come out here, they work hard.  They rarely take breaks and work through the entire trip.  The Chinese media?  When they get an assignment, they look at it as an opportunity to play tourist.  They see the sights.  They eat long meals at nice restaurants. They're not interested in the story."

    More seriously, there are regular instances of blackmail, wherein reporters have demanded money or other forms of compensation in return for keeping silent.

    Regardless, the tenacity and dedication on the part of so many other Chinese journalists is remarkable.

    "The controls on the media have been tighter than we've seen in a long time," said Bandurski.  "And yet there is still so much coverage [like the Hunan baby trafficking story] by places like Caixin coming out.  These organizations are pushing harder and harder and finding ways to do that kind of reporting."

    With additional reporting by Bo Gu.

    Related story: Growing calls in China to change the one-child policy

    Chinese babies sold for adoption in the U.S.?

  • Chinese babies sold for adoption in the U.S.?

    BEIJING – Since the early 1990s, more than 100,000 Chinese children have been adopted by families overseas – most of them in the U.S.

    And now it looks like some of the adoptees weren’t in fact orphans or unwanted offspring, but in fact children illegally snatched from their parents and sold to Chinese orphanages who brokered the adoptions – for as much as $3,000 a child adopted by foreigners.

    An investigative report released this week by the highly respected Chinese weekly publication, Caixin Century Magazine, found that from 2000 to 2005, local family planning officials in Hunan Province seized at least 16 children from households they claimed had violated the strict nationwide one-child policy. In almost every instance, when the parents could not pay the fine, their children were shipped off to an orphanage, which then sold them overseas.  Two of the children, their biological families believe, were adopted by American families.

    Caixin’s original report in Chinese spread rapidly around the Internet Tuesday, capturing widespread attention among netizens despite the fact that similar reports have surfaced in the years past. Even state-run media covered the story, describing a “stunned nation” upon hearing of the report.

    The allegations bring to light once more just one of the myriad problems China’s one-child policy has created in trying to address population pressures and poverty alleviation.  It also illustrates the potential for government corruption; career advancement in many instances depended on whether an official could demonstrate his or her ability to enforce the one-child policy.

    We could write more, but we encourage everyone to read the Caixin article here in an English translation.

    Related story: Time to re-evaluate China's one-child policy?

  • Growing calls in China to change the one-child policy

    China's new census shows its population growth rate is slowing down, raising the question whether it should still follow the one child policy. NBC's Adrienne Mong reports.   

    YICHENG COUNTY, SHANXI PROVINCE – It’s the kind of statistic that makes one pause.

    In 10 years, mainland China added 74 million more people.

    That’s about the size of Iran’s entire population.

    Adrienne Mong

    Children at a school in Yicheng County.

    But new figures from China’s latest census (2001-2010) also showed that the growth rate of its 1.34 billion-strong population is slowing down. Maybe too much.

    In fact, if looked at another way, the average population growth each year in China over the past ten years was 0.57 percent, down almost half of what it was from 1990 to 2000.

    Compare that to India, which has the world’s second largest population. It's population grew at an average rate of 1.7 percent a year in the same period.  Or the U.S., the world’s third largest population, which grew at an annual rate of 1.1 percent – the highest of any industrialized nation.

    Chinese state-run media, in reporting the census, have credited the one-child policy with curbing the nation’s population growth.

    But increasingly over the past year demographic experts within China have voiced skepticism about the family planning practices that limit urban couples to having only one child and rural couples and ethnic minority households to two. (More recently, parents have been allowed to have two if each parent is a single child him/herself.) They say China didn’t and doesn’t need such an extreme policy.

    An experiment within an experiment
    Liang Zhongtang is one of those skeptics.  A demographic expert affiliated with the Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences, Liang has been a long-time critic of the one-child policy – which has been in place for just over 30 years.

    “[Some Chinese] demographers said the population would be 300 or 400 million more without the birth control policy,” said Liang.  “I think it’s meaningless to talk about this issue. The decrease in the birth rate is the result of industrialization and modernization.”

    The slowing population growth rate, he continues, is just “a natural result as Chinese society develops.”

    Liang should know.

    Adrienne Mong

    A billboard outlining family planning guidelines in Xingtang.

    He’s responsible for an experiment within China’s great social engineering experiment: In Yicheng County in Shanxi Province, all families are allowed to have two children – as long as they follow two stipulations.

    “They can have another one as long as they wait four years [between the first and second child],” explained Wang Honglu, the family planning chief in Yichen's Xingtang town.

    The other is that couples wanting to have two children must be married at an age later than the national average marrying age. In China, the legal marrying age is 22 years for men and 20 years for women, but in Yicheng men must be 25 years and women 23 years if they want to marry.

    County officials devote a large part of their time to public awareness campaigns. Residents are encouraged to visit family planning clinics.  Authorities visit homes, especially after a couple has just wed, to distribute literature and discuss birth control methods.

    “We give out free condoms and birth control pills every month,” he said.  “Everything is free.”

    "This policy has been in effect since 1985," said Wang, who's worked in his field for 16 years.  "But our birth rate here has been lower than many other parts of the country [which did not have a two-child policy]."
     
    'Too expensive' to have children
    But talking to some families in Xingtang, it became clear that it wasn’t simply the existence of family planning that was keeping the birth rate low.

    “One reason to have only one child is to follow the nationwide policy,” said Wang Weigang, a 36-year-old who works in agriculture.  “But the other reason is economic.  It’s a big burden to bring up children.”

    Wang and his wife, Ma Zhengxia, decided to have only one child.  Their daughter, Yujie, is almost 2 years old. 

    “I’m not going to consider having another child for sure,” said Wang.

    In fact, that’s exactly the sentiments of Wang Honglu, the family planning official.  He is also 36 and has a daughter who is 12 years old. 

    “It’s just too expensive in general,” he said. 

    Both Wang families said they wanted to be able to afford to pay for school fees and other expenses for their daughters. 

    But like many aspiring middle class households in China who are seeing the cost of living skyrocket as their quality of life improves, they also want to have enough money to buy their own home and a car. 

    Yicheng’s experience, says Liang – the man who designed the county's experimental two-child policy, shows that “a looser [birth control] policy is better than a strict policy.”

    More problems than solutions

    Even if Liang is right, there are other compelling reasons for the government to reconsider its views on family planning.

    “China doesn’t have overpopulation pressure,” said Zhang Juwei, the deputy chief of the Population and Labor Economics Institute at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.  “A structural imbalance is the real problem we’re facing.”

    By that, Zhang means a whole host of problems that the one-child policy has engendered.

    Adrienne Mong

    By the time this little fellow's marrying age, there might not be enough single Chinese women to go around.

    “Like the distribution of people in the rural and urban areas, like aging, like the gender imbalance.  These are the problems we are facing, not too much growth,” he continued.

    Key findings of the new census confirmed Zhang’s points, even prompting the official Communist Party newspaper, the People’s Daily, to say “a crisis looms” and giving rise to a catchphrase found in much of the Western media coverage, that “China will grow older before it gets richer.”

    Among the findings:

    - the number of people age 60 or over has grown nearly 3 percent while the number of people under 14 has decreased by more than six percent;

    - the male to female ratio among newborns is roughly 118 to 100, higher than the 116 to 100 ratio of boys to girls in 2000;

    - the number of urban residents has increased to just over 49 percent of the nationwide population, up 13 percent.

    A rapidly growing aging population, combined with a shrinking low-cost labor pool, is worrying.  All last year, reports of a labor shortage in China’s manufacturing belts in the south and east were on the rise.  Add to that, the growing urbanization rate –residents moving from the countryside to seek work in the cities – means the country will have to change its economic growth model.  It can no longer depend on cheap labor or, ultimately, on being the “factory of the world.”

    The highly skewed ratio of men to women brings with it many social implications, particularly for a government that says it’s pursuing a “harmonious society.”  Although to be fair, the one-child policy is not the sole reason for the imbalance.  In many parts of the country, particularly in rural areas, families have a traditional preference for sons.

    Officials in Beijing know all this, and since late 2009 the debate over family planning has been played out openly in the local media.  And there have been regular reports about the possibility of loosening the policy or allowing families in certain regions to have two children.

    Even so, any changes – if they were to happen – would be over several years.  Pilot schemes have been mentioned, in which five or six provinces may allow couples to have two children under certain circumstances.  But a nationwide two-child policy was unlikely at the very least until 2015.

    At any rate, President Hu Jintao finally waded into the fray two weeks ago when Xinhua reported his comments in a politburo meeting that there would be no change to the one-child policy.

  • Kung Fu panda kills peacock in China

    BEIJING - Just one month before “Kung Fu Panda 2,” the sequel to the blockbuster animated hit from 2008, comes to China, a 5-year-old panda practiced his kung fu in a zoo in China’s central province of Hubei and killed his neighbor: a blue peacock.

    On the morning of May 2, Chen Jun, the zookeeper at Wuhan Zoo in Hubei, was cleaning the interior of the panda’s house when he heard piecing squeaks outside. Hope, a male panda, was dragging a peacock in his mouth, running fast in circles. When the poor blue peacock tried to escape Hope’s paws, the bear caught the bird again, bit off her tail and dragged her around inside the enclosure. Finally the panda decided to take a break, placed the peacock on his wooden play rack, and watched her die – just like cats play with their prey.

    The Wuhan Zoo keeps the peacock enclosure next door to the panda house, with a ten-foot tall fence between the two. For the past three years, peacocks have been flying over the fence to their cuddly neighbors’ territory to hunt for worms and seeds. The zookeepers said sometimes the pandas would get excited and chase the birds for a little bit, but they had never seen one act like Hope or kill any birds.

    CCTV footage (see above) later revealed just how energetic Hope was on that morning, chasing the peacock for quite a long time.

    The zookeeper also explained in an interview with China’s Central Television that a 5-year-old male panda is like a 20-year-old boy: at the peak of his powers, full of energy.

  • Beijing's arts community soldiers on without its patron saint

    BEIJING—With all that’s been written about the disappearance of the patron saint of Beijing’s arts community, Ai Weiwei, and the increasingly challenging environment for free speech in China, it was interesting to see the crowds that turned out this weekend to enjoy an unfettered and uncensored prestigious international annual photography festival.

    Courtesy of artist Liu Di and Pekin Fine Arts

    "Animal Regulation NO. 4" by Liu Di (2010)

    In just over ten years, Caochangdi has developed from a sleepy rural hamlet in the capital’s northeast into a lively neighborhood (at least on the weekends) of studios and galleries that, unlike the 798 arts district closer to the city center, still retains some of its grittiness.

    And it was Ai who pioneered Caochangdi’s development.  In 2000, the man many have called the father of contemporary Chinese art set himself up in the area, building a gray brick-and-cement compound that became a template of sorts for the artists, studios, and galleries who followed his lead.

    But it’s been exactly one month now since anyone has seen or heard from Ai, who was detained at Beijing’s airport on April 3.  Chinese officials refuse to comment on his status or his whereabouts although the Chinese embassy in London did say just last week there is an ongoing investigation into his finances. 

    The mysterious circumstances surrounding his detention has heightened anxiety in the local arts community.  “This kind of thing—an artist that is highly respected and well-known disappearing is disturbing, to put it mildly,” said one gallery manager who wished to remain anonymous because of the topic’s sensitivity.  (A Chinese journalist who has covered Ai’s disappearance as well as other controversial matters has just been reported missing for three days).

    Adrienne Mong

    The gate to Ai Weiwei's studio in Caochangdi, Beijing.

    Ai’s arrest is only the most high-profile of a couple dozen arrests of activists and lawyers this year, reflecting “the increasingly thuggish and unlawful conduct of Chinese security forces in stifling perceived dissent,” said Phelim Kine, a researcher with the U.S.-based Human Rights Watch organization.

    Even the U.S. has described the situation in China as a “serious back-sliding on human rights”—as a senior official visiting Beijing for a two-day human rights dialogue did last week.

    Young Chinese photographers flourish
    Under this cloud, Caochangdi PhotoSpring kicked off its second annual run.  Around 170 international artists, principally Chinese, are taking part in the event — the result of a three-year partnership with the world-renown Les Rencontres d’Arles Photography Festival based in the south of France.

    Chief among the events during the month-long festival is the 2011 Three Shadows Photography Award Exhibition, which features works by semifinalists selected from across China, each one reflecting an extremely personal theme.

    Take, for example, a series of sensuous black and white self-portrait prints by Xu Lijing.  The caption reads, “Self-portraits are the objectification of the subconscious….  You examine photography and it examines you.”

    Another photographer submitted a series called “Summer Ocean Love.”  The collection of color prints depicts a summer “in the last seven years” of the life of the artist, who is interested in exploring happenings “related to my own life.”

    “You can see these young photographers today are more focused on personal themes, personal matters, than they are on larger issues.” said RongRong, a founder and director of Three Shadows Photography Art Centre as well as a director of Caochangdi PhotoSpring.  “Especially the balinghou (or those born after 1980).”

    A public fixture in Chinese photography since the 1990s, RongRong sees a great difference between the generation of photographers to which he belongs and the current crop of up-and-coming artists.

    “When I was growing up, there was no Internet. I had much less connection with other people,” he said.  “But young photographers today can connect easily with anyone.”

    The irony is not lost on RongRong or others.  “Young photographers are so exposed, they almost have to internalize everything,” said Bérénice Angremy, another PhotoSpring director.  “The significance is the opening up of [Chinese] society.”

    By He Chongyue, Courtesy of Caochangdi PhotoSpring

    He Chongyue, "The End: Family Planning Series No 12," 2010

    Some sensitive themes explored in PhotoSpring
    RongRong’s own work is also on display at the festival—with a theme far removed from the deeply personal ones expressed by the younger photographers.  His “Ruin Pictures 1996-1998” documents the destruction of traditional dwellings in Beijing:

    “Vivid testimony of the lives and interests of former occupants, the poignancy of these photographs is intensified by awareness that their owners had no choice in their relocation.”

    In fact, quite a few major works showing at the nearly 30 galleries and arts institutions as part of PhotoSpring focus on sensitive topics that could raise authorities’ eyebrows: surveillance, wrongful prison convictions, the transformation of the Chinese urban landscape (and by extension, hints at illegal land seizures and forced evictions), and the one-child policy.

    These are themes that have much in common with the social criticism and activism that Ai engaged in latterly in his life. 

    Ai has played no role in PhotoSpring.  Nevertheless his absence has been felt deeply in Caochangdi and beyond, demoralizing—as one person put it—the arts community.

    “Of course, the situation [with Ai’s disappearance] has had an impact,” said inri, a director of Caochangdi PhotoSpring as well as founder of the Three Shadows Photography Art Centre.

    After all, the month-long festival is as much about providing a network and platform for photographers to engage with one another as it is about introducing fine arts photography to a wider audience in Beijing.

    And the notion of nurturing Chinese talent was one of the great Ai hallmarks.

    “A lot of young artists have come here from the provinces to try to make a career in Beijing, and he helped them,” said Meg Maggio, owner and founder of Pékin Fine Arts.  “He helped them find places to live.  He helped them find work.  He helped them get recognized in the art world.  And this was all since the 1990s.”

    Wrongful convictions
    It seemed fitting then to be looking at one particular exhibit comprising large photographs of wrongfully convicted men and women.  In her series called “The Innocents,” Taryn Simon took portraits of individuals who served time in prison for “violent crimes they did not commit,” after being mistakenly identified with the use of photographic technology. 

    All of the subjects posed in scenes that led to their “illegitimate” conviction.  (An eerie echo of some of Ai’s previous run-ins with the authorities, when he would photograph or record police officers during their encounters.)  

    Their experience, according to Simon, raises the question whether photography is a “credible eyewitness and arbiter of justice.”

    One wonders what kind of photographic evidence Chinese authorities are building in their case against Ai Weiwei.

    Related story: The show goes on in New York, minus detained Chinse artist

    SLIDESHOW of Ai Weiwei's work